Silicon Valley Bank’s recent insolvency has raised questions about ethical responsibility, including the role of the bank’s management and its board of directors. Ethical responsibility for the bank’s failure is also shared by Congress and the Trump White House’s loosening of regulations. In implementing lessons from SVB’s insolvency, we need to strengthen genuine corporate ethics, including a focus on governance and an understanding of how corporate values should be expressed in day-to-day business. The CIA’s approach to ethical behavior may offer valuable lessons for corporations, as it reinforces ethical standards on an organizational level and provides its officers with a framework for making ethical judgments in their morally ambiguous world. For an organization to be truly ethical, all its members must understand the core values that guide it and how those values are expressed in their daily work. The consequences of SVB’s failure underscore the need for a broader understanding of corporate social responsibility.
Using Spies to Teach Corporate America about Ethics
The recent failure of Silicon Valley Bank has led to some interesting insights about the importance of professional and organizational ethics. One unconventional place to look for guidance in this area is the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Although the agency is not typically associated with ethical behavior, the ways in which it reinforces ethical standards on an organizational level can provide valuable lessons for the corporate world.
In a recent talk about professional and organizational ethics, a group of junior CIA spies learned about the practical rules and considerations that should guide their actions. While the CIA’s clandestine service is known for deceit and manipulation, it’s important for intelligence officers to have an accepted framework for making ethical judgments in their morally ambiguous world. The ethical responsibilities of spies extend beyond their own organization to all Americans, who empower and hold them accountable.
One key lesson from the CIA’s approach to ethics is the importance of a shared understanding of core values. For an organization to truly operate with ethics, all members must understand these values and how they apply in their daily work. This understanding must be widely accepted and communicated so that even junior practitioners feel empowered to hold their superiors accountable for following these values.
While ethics in espionage is nothing new, the way the CIA promotes ethical behavior on an organizational level is innovative and may provide insights for corporations facing their own ethical dilemmas.
The Importance of Governance in ESG Policies
ESG, or environmental, social, and governance policies, has become a popular topic in the U.S. financial sector. However, ESG as currently practiced is largely a top-down phenomenon, divorced from daily business fundamentals. While the “E” and “S” are important, effective ESG policies require a focus on governance tied to a broad sense of corporate social responsibility.
The genuine stakeholders in a business extend far beyond its shareholders, and its operations must take those stakeholders into account. For a G-centered ESG policy to be effective, corporate social responsibility must permeate the entire culture of an organization. This requires an understanding of how corporate values should be practically expressed in one’s day-to-day business, even in situations that are hard to anticipate.
The recent failure of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) illustrates the importance of governance in ESG policies. SVB provided banking services to nearly half of the country’s venture capital-backed technology and life-sciences companies, as well as to some 2,500 VC firms. Despite its extensive influence and responsibility, SVB’s ESG report conveys little that’s relevant to the failings that led to its demise.
The combination of social responsibility and indications of financial distress may have informed the decisions of SVB’s management before its sudden fall. This highlights the need for a broader understanding of corporate social responsibility and the importance of governance in ESG policies.
Examining Ethical Responsibility in SVB’s Insolvency
Silicon Valley Bank’s (SVB) recent insolvency has raised questions about ethical responsibility, including that of the bank’s CEO who sold $3.6 million in personal shares just 11 days before it was shut down. Other executives also reportedly handed out bonuses just hours before the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation stepped in. The board, which included eminent names in U.S. business, is also under scrutiny for their knowledge of the bank’s situation and how they acted on it.
However, ethical responsibility for SVB’s insolvency is not limited to the bank’s management. Congress and the Trump White House’s loosening of regulations, driven by lobbying from those whose negligence produced the crisis, must also share the blame. Still, SVB and others cannot excuse their own failings.
The postmortem on SVB is only beginning, and it will likely include criticism of corporate greed and lack of government regulation. But to prevent similar situations, we need to strengthen genuine corporate ethics. This includes a focus on governance and an understanding of how corporate values should be expressed in day-to-day business, even in unexpected situations.
The example of the CIA’s approach to ethical behavior may offer valuable lessons for corporations. The CIA reinforces ethical standards on an organizational level and provides its officers with a framework for making ethical judgments in their morally ambiguous world. For an organization to be truly ethical, all its members must understand the core values that guide it and how those values are expressed in their daily work. This understanding must be widely accepted and communicated so that even junior practitioners feel empowered to hold their superiors accountable for following these values.
In implementing these lessons, we must not forget the role of ethical responsibility in preventing crises like SVB’s insolvency. The consequences of SVB’s failure have threatened the entire financial structure of a continental nation, underscoring the need for a broader understanding of corporate social responsibility.
Don’t miss interesting posts on Famousbio
